vs
AT&T vs Xfinity in Indianapolis
Indianapolis shoppers trade AT&T’s faster fiber uploads and lower starting price against Xfinity’s strong cable performance where available.
Xfinity is the better overall pick in Indianapolis because it delivers a strong balance of availability, performance, and starting price for everyday households. AT&T wins on speed, with a 5,000/5,000 Mbps fiber option where available, while AT&T also wins coverage and price at $35/mo versus Xfinity’s $40/mo. Xfinity is right for shoppers who want a solid cable connection and broad access within its service area; AT&T is better for fiber seekers, upload-heavy work, and budget-minded households where it reaches your address. Check availability before choosing.
At a glance
AT&T vs. Xfinity, side by side.
| Provider | Type | Top speed | City coverage | Starting price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AT&T |
Fiber | 5 Gig 5 Gig upload |
94% | $35/mo | Top fiber speeds |
| Xfinity |
Cable | 2 Gig 300 Mbps upload |
61% | $40/mo | Solid cable option |
Coverage map
Two different questions, two views. Top speed shows who offers the faster plan where you can actually get it. Coverage shows who reaches more of each ZIP. Or pick a single provider to see just its footprint.
Neighborhood breakdown
The head-to-head can shift by ZIP code and neighborhood because coverage varies block to block. AT&T reaches about 94% of Indianapolis across technologies, while Xfinity reaches about 61%, but the fastest tiers reach smaller areas, so check your exact address.
| ZIP | Neighborhoods | Coverage | Top speed | Rank score | Winner | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AT&T | Xfinity | AT&T | Xfinity | AT&T | Xfinity | |||
| 46203 | Fountain Square, Fletcher Place, Bates-Hendricks, Garfield Park | 81% | 31% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 77 | 25 | AT&T |
| 46219 | Irvington, Warren Township, East Indianapolis | 79% | 60% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 75 | 49 | AT&T |
| 46218 | Martindale-Brightwood, Near Northeast, Forest Manor, Brookside | 61% | 11% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 58 | 9 | AT&T |
| 46202 | Downtown, Herron-Morton, Fall Creek Place, IUPUI | 41% | 30% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 39 | 24 | AT&T |
| 46220 | Broad Ripple, Meridian-Kessler, SoBro, Glendale | 84% | 56% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 80 | 46 | AT&T |
| 46226 | Devington, Lawrence, Eastgate, Arlington Woods | 79% | 72% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 75 | 59 | AT&T |
| 46201 | Near Eastside, Englewood, Woodruff Place, Cottage Home | 85% | 6% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 81 | 5 | AT&T |
| 46241 | Mars Hill, West Indianapolis, Airport Area | 64% | 99% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 61 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46205 | Mapleton-Fall Creek, Meridian-Kessler, Highland-Kennedy King, Forest Manor | 63% | 24% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 60 | 20 | AT&T |
| 46208 | Butler-Tarkington, Crown Hill, Mapleton-Fall Creek, Riverside | 52% | 7% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 49 | 6 | AT&T |
| 46227 | Southport, University Heights, Perry Township, Garfield Park South | 84% | 90% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 79 | 74 | AT&T |
| 46239 | Franklin Township, Wanamaker, Cumberland | 50% | 97% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 47 | 80 | Xfinity |
| 46222 | Haughville, Speedway area, Stringtown, Near Westside | 68% | 26% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 64 | 22 | AT&T |
| 46256 | Geist, Castleton, Oakandale | 61% | 98% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 58 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46234 | Eagle Creek, Chapel Hill, Ben Davis | 49% | 73% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 47 | 60 | Xfinity |
| 46260 | Nora, Spring Mill, Meridian Hills, Williams Creek | 64% | 97% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 60 | 80 | Xfinity |
| 46236 | Geist, Oakland Hills, Sunnyside | 22% | 99% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 21 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46221 | West Indianapolis, Valley Mills, Mars Hill, Decatur Township | 53% | 65% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 50 | 53 | Xfinity |
| 46231 | Ben Davis, Camby, Bridgeport | 47% | 61% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 45 | 50 | Xfinity |
| 46268 | Pike Township, College Park, Eagle Creek, Michigan Road corridor | 52% | 94% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 49 | 77 | Xfinity |
| 46259 | Acton, Franklin Township, Wanamaker | 24% | 93% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 23 | 77 | Xfinity |
| 46237 | Southport, Perry Township, Wanamaker | 62% | 96% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 59 | 79 | Xfinity |
| 46217 | Southport, Perry Township, University Heights | 63% | 98% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 60 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46278 | Pike Township, Eagle Creek, Zionsville Road area, Traders Point | 21% | 94% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 20 | 77 | Xfinity |
| 46240 | Nora, Meridian-Kessler, Keystone at the Crossing | 69% | 99% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 65 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46225 | Bates-Hendricks, Garfield Park, Old Southside, University Heights | 56% | 28% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 54 | 23 | AT&T |
| 46254 | Eagle Creek, Georgetown, Traders Point | 58% | 90% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 56 | 74 | Xfinity |
| 46224 | Speedway, Ben Davis, Eagledale, Westside | 78% | 83% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 74 | 68 | AT&T |
| 46229 | Cumberland, Warren Township, Buck Creek | 74% | 99% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 71 | 81 | Xfinity |
| 46204 | Downtown, Mile Square, Massachusetts Avenue, Wholesale District | 24% | 44% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 23 | 36 | Xfinity |
| 46250 | Castleton, Nora, Allisonville | 54% | 100% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 51 | 82 | Xfinity |
| 46235 | Post Road, Lawrence, Grassy Creek | 50% | 82% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 48 | 67 | Xfinity |
| 46214 | Eagle Creek, Ben Davis, Speedway area, Westside | 59% | 100% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 56 | 82 | Xfinity |
| 46290 | Nora, Meridian-Kessler area, North Meridian corridor | 72% | 64% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 68 | 53 | AT&T |
| 46228 | Crooked Creek, Butler-Tarkington, Michigan Road | 82% | 90% | 5 Gig | 1 Gig | 78 | 74 | AT&T |
| 46280 | Nora, Carmel (south), Home Place | 81% | 35% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 77 | 29 | AT&T |
| 46244 | Downtown Indianapolis | 12% | 52% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 12 | 42 | Xfinity |
| 46230 | Broad Ripple | 97% | 17% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 92 | 14 | AT&T |
| 46216 | Fort Benjamin Harrison, Lawrence | 49% | 96% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 47 | 79 | Xfinity |
| 46242 | Speedway Area | 62% | 100% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 59 | 82 | Xfinity |
| 46251 | Southwest Indianapolis | 62% | 100% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 59 | 82 | Xfinity |
| 46206 | Downtown (PO Boxes), Indianapolis | 24% | 43% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 23 | 35 | Xfinity |
| 46247 | Southside Indianapolis | 93% | 100% | 5 Gig | 2 Gig | 88 | 82 | AT&T |
Rank score (0–100) is each provider’s Speed Score, discounted for weak upload, times the share of that ZIP it reaches — the same rule that orders providers on the Indianapolis city page, so it moves as availability changes street to street.
Which is better for…
The right pick comes down to what you actually do online.
Get connected
Pick your provider and check availability at your address.
- 5 Gig down · 5 Gig up Fiber
- 1 Gig down · 1 Gig up Fiber
- 100 Mbps down · 20 Mbps up Copper
- 2 Gig down · 300 Mbps up Cable
- 1 Gig down · 35 Mbps up Cable
See what’s actually available at your address
Coverage changes from one street to the next. Check your exact address in seconds.
Check my addressFrequently asked questions
Is AT&T or Xfinity available at my Indianapolis address?
AT&T reaches about 94% of Indianapolis, while Xfinity reaches about 61% across all technologies. Availability can vary block to block, and faster tiers cover less of the city, so check your exact address before ordering.
Which is cheaper, AT&T or Xfinity, and what will I actually pay?
AT&T starts at $35/mo, while Xfinity starts at $40/mo. These are promotional starting rates, so confirm the post-promo rate, equipment fees, and any contract before signing.
Which is faster for gaming, work from home, or 4K streaming?
AT&T can reach 5,000/5,000 Mbps on fiber, while Xfinity can reach 2,000/300 Mbps on cable where available. AT&T is the stronger choice for upload-heavy gaming and work from home, but check which tier reaches your address.
More Indianapolis comparisons
How Indianapolis’s other qualifying providers stack up head-to-head.